Energy Storage Equity: An Assessment of Three Massachusetts Programs

Client: Clean Energy Group

Authors: Tanya Stasio, PhD, Elisabeth Seliga, Bryndis Woods, PhD, and Elizabeth A. Stanton, PhD

September 2024

On behalf of the Clean Energy Group (CEG), Researcher Tanya Stasio, PhD, Assistant Researcher Elisabeth Seliga, Principal Analyst Bryndis Woods, PhD and Principal Economist Liz Stanton, PhD assessed equity provisions in three Massachusetts energy storage-incentivizing programs: the Solar Massachusetts Renewable Target (SMART) program, the Clean Peak Standard, and ConnectedSolutions. AEC finds that three energy programs assessed lack mandates, targets and reporting requirements to support the Commonwealth’s commitment to equitable access to clean and efficient energy. AEC makes eight recommendations to better align Massachusetts’ energy storage programs with its equity commitments, as well as to draw on lessons learned and best practices from similar programs in other states.

Link to Report

Return to Our Work

Illinois Adult Use Cannabis Industry Disparity Study

Client: Illinois Cannabis Regulation Oversight Office

Authors: Elizabeth A. Stanton, PhD, Bryndis Woods, PhD, Tanya Stasio, PhD, Jordan Burt, Deja Garraway, Nayantara Biswas, and Alannah Shute

July 2024

On behalf of the Illinois Cannabis Regulation Oversight Office, AEC assisted the Nerevu Group, LLC in preparing a disparity study to evaluate and assess existing discrimination within the State of Illinois cannabis industry. In particular, AEC staff reviewed public and private data sources to provide utilization, availability, and disparity analyses for the Illinois economy and the Illinois cannabis industry. AEC finds evidence of significant disparities in Illinois business ownership and wages across race/ethnicity and gender. Specifically, AEC finds that, compared to White men, racial and/or ethnic minorities and women are less likely to be business owners and have less access to capital through either hourly wages or bank loans.

To cultivate a more inclusive and equitable industry, Nerevu Group, LLC recommends broadening availability of financing for cannabis businesses, improved data management, consolidating of the Illinois regulatory structure, additional disparity studies, and more industry-state collaboration along with a set of administrative recommendations.

Link to Report

Return to Our Work

Home Heating in Massachusetts: What Influences Future Costs?

Client: Home Energy Efficiency Team (HEET)

Author: Tanya Stasio, PhD, Joshua R. Castigliego, Sumera Patel, and Elizabeth A. Stanton, PhD

March 2024

On behalf of the Home Energy Efficiency Team (HEET), Researchers Tanya Stasio and Joshua R. Castigliego, Assistant Researcher Sumera Patel, and Senior Economist Elizabeth A. Stanton prepared a white paper that estimates the average home heating costs faced by Massachusetts households using different heating technologies.

This March 2024 AEC white paper updates the home heating cost analysis conducted in AEC’s January 2021 white paper; both analyses present operating costs only, excluding the costs of purchasing or maintaining heating equipment. Updated analysis, based on the most recent data and cost projections, finds that heating with networked geothermal and ground-source heat pumps is less expensive than heating with gas-fired furnaces today and can be expected to remain so through 2050. Our findings regarding air-source heat pumps, however, point to more questions than answers: Changes in gas and electric prices over the past few years reversed our earlier findings, suggesting that notoriously uncertain forecasts of future fuel prices are of paramount importance in understanding the likely impacts of ASHP adoption on household finances.

Link to White Paper

Return to our Work

Distributed Energy Storage: The Missing Piece in North Carolina's Decarbonization Efforts

Client: Clean Energy Group (CEG)

Author: Tanya Stasio, PhD, Elisabeth Seliga, Deja Garraway, Bryndis Woods, PhD, Elizabeth A. Stanton, PhD

December 2023

On behalf of the Clean Energy Group (CEG), Researcher Tanya Stasio, Assistant Researcher Elisabeth Seliga, Researcher Deja Torrence, Senior Researcher Bryndis Woods, and Senior Economist Elizabeth A. Stanton prepared a report that identifies distributed energy storage as the missing piece in North Carolina's decarbonization efforts. Distributed energy storage can provide load management to help meet peak electric demand and reduce the need for costly and polluting fossil fuel peaker plants. When paired with solar PV, distributed energy storage batteries can provide clean backup power to improve energy resilience while reducing home energy bills.

To support North Carolina’s decarbonization efforts and equity goals, this report makes three key policy recommendations for increasing incentives and lowering barriers to distributed energy storage deployment:

1. Approve and expand utility deployment of equitable distributed solar and distributed energy storage pilot programs.

2. Create statewide financial incentives for residential and community-based distributed solar and behind-the-meter battery installations.

3. Establish equity, climate, and energy performance-based metrics and targets for electric utilities.

Link to the Report

Return to our Work

Massachusetts MLPs Exemption from RPS: Impacts on Clean Energy

Client: Prepared on behalf of Massachusetts Climate Action Network

Authors: Tanya Stasio, PhD, Elisabeth Seliga, Liz Stanton, PhD

April 2023

On behalf of the Massachusetts Climate Action Network, Researcher Dr. Tanya Stasio, Assistant Researcher Elisabeth Seliga, and Senior Economist Dr. Liz Stanton prepared a presentation on the Massachusetts Municipal Light Plant (MLP) exemption from the Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS) and the impact on clean energy in the Commonwealth. AEC finds that the MLP Greenhouse Gas Emissions Standard, and the RPS exemption, allow MLPs to remain at today's level of Class I renewable energy sources, resulting in substantially less clean energy in the Commonwealth than if MLPs were required to comply with the RPS.

This work was presented at the April 19th, 2023 MCAN Legislative Launch titled, "Advancing Clean Energy, Equity, and Innovation in Municipal Utilities." For more information, or to watch the recording of the event, visit the MCAN website here.

Link to Presentation

Return to Our Work

Electric Justice: A Toolkit for the Mid-Atlantic Region

Prepared on behalf of PJM Cities and Communities Coalition

Authors: Tanya Stasio, PhD, Elisabeth Seliga, Sachin Peddada, Elizabeth A. Stanton, PhD

Energy decisions affect everyone, but local communities and businesses often lack the time and resources needed to engage in grid operator decision-making. On behalf of the PJM Cities and Communities Coalition, AEC Researcher Tanya Stasio, PhD, Assistant Researchers Elisabeth Seliga and Sachin Peddada, and Senior Economist Liz Stanton, PhD developed a report to assist coalition members and other consumer groups in advocating for greater equity in PJM Interconnection decision-making. This resource was developed with the invaluable input of representatives of organizations that sponsored the Fix the Grid campaign in New England, which is focused on rejecting fossil fuels and calling for a just and democratic energy grid.

Link to Report

Return to Our Work

Cumulative Impact Assessment of the North Brooklyn Pipeline Project

Prepared on behalf of Sane Energy and Alliance for a Green Economy

Author: Tanya Stasio, PhD, Jordan Burt, Elisabeth Seliga, Sachin Peddada, Elizabeth A. Stanton, PhD

The National Grid Phase 5 expansion of fossil fuel infrastructure and the Vaporizer 13/14 project at the Greenpoint Energy Center create a multi-pronged set of threats to the North Brooklyn communities.

AEC Researcher Tanya Stasio, PhD, Research Assistant Jordan Burt, Assistant Researchers Elisabeth Seliga and Sachin Peddada, and Senior Economist, Liz Stanton, PhD  have prepared a cumulative impact assessment on behalf of Sane Energy and Alliance for a Green Economy to highlight the existing and overlapping socioeconomic, environmental, and health-related burdens facing the communities living near the pending Phase 5 pipeline construction and vaporizer additions at the Greenpoint Energy Center. AEC finds that the Bushwick, Bedford, and Williamsburg neighborhoods would be impacted the most from these fossil fuel expansion projects and include densely populated communities with majority BIPOC and low-income residents.

Link to Report

Return to Our Work

Boston Tree Equity Analysis

Client: GreenRoots and Speak for the Trees

Authors: Tanya Stasio, PhD, Elisabeth Seliga, Elizabeth A. Stanton, PhD

Boston’s trees provide shade, cooling, and flood protection, and are an important tool for mitigating climate change impacts—like increased precipitation, sea level rise, and higher temperatures. The distribution of trees across and within Boston neighborhoods determines which communities benefit from these protections and which are left bearing the brunt of climate change impacts.

On behalf of GreenRoots and Speak for the Trees, Researcher Tanya Stasio, PhD, Assistant Researcher Elisabeth Seliga and Senior Economist Liz Stanton, PhD examined the distribution of tree coverage, pollution, high temperatures, and socioeconomic disparities in the City of Boston in order to identify communities where tree planting efforts could offer the most equitable results.

AEC recommends that equitable tree planting efforts be concentrated in neighborhoods where there is both the greatest opportunity for planting trees in an otherwise tree scarce area and a high concentration of socially vulnerable populations: South Boston, East Boston, Dorchester, and Roxbury.

Link to Report

Return to Our Work

Bringing Equity into Energy Reliability Decisions

Client: Environmental Defense Fund

Authors: Bryndis Woods, PhD, Sachin Peddada, Sagal Alisalad, Jordan Burt, Elisabeth Seliga, Tanya Stasio, PhD, Eliandro Tavares, Grace Wu, Elizabeth A. Stanton, PhD

AEC staff prepared a report on behalf of the Environmental Defense Fund that analyzes the connection between issues of energy system reliability and equity. This data-driven report utilizes case studies of advocates’ for more equitable energy systems real-world experiences to assess how decision-makers should account for equity when making decisions regarding system reliability. The report concludes with recommendations for future decision-making in energy system reliability, including strengthening consumer and community representation. A common theme across the real-world experiences of the advocates discussed in this report is the ways in which community engagement efforts in energy system decision-making often fall short of creating real change in energy sector decisions, and environmental justice and other under-resourced and underserved communities are often left out and left behind in decisions that directly disproportionately harm the health and wealth of their communities.

Link to Full Report

Link to Press Release

Return to Our Work

Overburdened Communities and Power Plants in New Jersey

Authors: Researcher Tanya Stasio, PhD, Assistant Researchers Sagal Alisalad, Elisabeth Seliga, and Sachin Peddada, and Research Assistant Jordan Burt

Researcher Tanya Stasio, PhD, Assistant Researchers Sagal Alisalad, Elisabeth Seliga, and Sachin Peddada, and Research Assistant Jordan Burt prepared a policy brief on how New Jersey power plants disproportionately affect overburdened communities.

New Jersey environmental justice law defines overburdened communities as census blocks where at least a third of the household is low income, 40 percent of residents identify as racial-ethnic minorities, or 40 percent have low English proficiency. These communities are disproportionately affected by the pollutants emitted by power plants. AEC researchers explain that environmental justice initiatives will require full understanding of the impacts on vulnerable communities.

Link to Policy Brief

Return to Our Work

Entergy Louisiana IRP Comments

Author: Tyler Comings

July 2022

AEC Senior Researcher Tyler Comings co-authored comments (along with Sierra Club) on Entergy Louisiana's Integrated Resource Plan (IRP). The comments ask Entergy to include more reasonable costs for renewable and storage resources, to model more early retirement options for its coal units, and fully capture the costs of using hydrogen fuel.

Link to Comments

Link to Comments on Draft IRP

Return to Our Work

Barriers and Opportunities for Green Jobs in New Jersey

Authors: Bryndis Woods, PhD, Joshua R. Castigliego, Elisabeth Seliga, Sachin Peddada, Tanya Stasio, PhD, Liz Stanton, PhD

June 2022

Senior Researcher Bryndis Woods, PhD, Researcher Joshua Castigliego, Assistant Researchers Elisabeth Seliga and Sachin Peddada, Researcher Tanya Stasio, PhD, and Senior Economist Liz Stanton, PhD prepared a report that assesses New Jersey’s current clean energy workforce, identifies barriers to green jobs that impede access to—and equitable representation within—the clean energy sector, and provides recommendations regarding how the State of New Jersey can shape policy and regulations to enhance the equity, diversity and inclusion of its clean energy jobs. AEC staff find that there are important barriers to green jobs that reinforce existing inequities in New Jersey’s clean energy workforce, including: educational/experience barriers, logistical barriers, equitable access barriers, and institutional barriers. Achieving a future of clean energy jobs in New Jersey that is diverse, equitable and inclusive will require overcoming barriers to green jobs with intentional efforts targeted at marginalized and underrepresented groups, such as racial/ethnic minorities, women, low-income households, and people with limited English proficiency.

In a companion publication to this report—Economic Impacts of a Clean Energy Transition in New Jersey—AEC assesses the job and other economic impacts associated with achieving a clean energy transition in New Jersey over the next few decades. 

Link to Report

Link to Presentation

Link to Press Release

Media Coverage - NJBiz - June 9, 2022

Media Coverage - NJ Spotlight News - June 8, 2022

Media Coverage - Asbury Park Press - June 8, 2022

Media Coverage - NJ101.5 - June 7, 2022

Return to Our Work

Risk Assessment of Florida Power and Light and NextEra Energy Clean Energy Transition Plans

Client: Environmental Defense Fund

Authors: Tanya Stasio, Joshua Castigliego, Chirag Lala, and Liz Stanton, PhD

May 2022

On behalf of the Environmental Defense Fund, Researchers Tanya Stasio, Joshua Castigliego, Chirag Lala, and Director and Senior Economist Liz Stanton, PhD make recommendations for Florida Power and Light (FPL) to assist the utility in embracing the clean energy transition and reduce risks to ratepayers and its parent company, NextEra Energy's, shareholders.

Utilities across the United States are pursuing net-zero emissions targets while NextEra, the only large utility parent company that lacks an absolute carbon reduction goal, aims to reduce carbon intensity by 67 percent of 2005 levels by 2025. Moreover, FPL’s plans for the future are not aligned with NextEra’s emission rate reduction target. Based on AEC's assessment of FPL/NextEra’s transition plans and a review of electric utility climate plans, AEC offers seven recommendations for a new transition plan:

1. Coordinate NextEra and FPL transition plans

2. Establish short-, medium-, and long-term emission reduction targets, including a net zero target

3. Ramp up demand-side management efforts

4. Invest in energy storage technologies

5. Modernize the electric grid and increase renewable energy capacity

6. Consider multiple scenarios in future planning and reduce planning time horizon

7. Increase stakeholder and community engagement and continue to align plan with TCFD recommendations

Link to Report (updated May 16, 2022)

Link to Executive Summary

Return to Our Work

Decarbonizing Building Heat in Massachusetts

Client: HEET

Authors: Tanya Stasio, Joshua Castigliego, Sagal Alisalad, and Liz Stanton, PhD.

March 2022

On behalf of the HEET, Researchers Tanya Stasio and Joshua Castigliego, Assistant Researcher Sagal Alisalad, and Director and Senior Economist Liz Stanton, PhD explored the feasibility of injecting green hydrogen and/or upgraded biogas (also known as “renewable” natural gas) into Massachusetts’ existing gas supply as a building decarbonization strategy. AEC compared these alternatives to gas heating and modern electric heat pumps in terms of price, feasibility, supply, and safety, and found that upgraded biogas and green hydrogen are infeasible, expensive, and unsafe strategies for decarbonization of building heating. Moreover, a green hydrogen/fossil gas blend is not feasible before 2040; For a green hydrogen/fossil gas blend to be a viable heating fuel, gas utilities would need to replace all of Massachusetts’ leaky-prone pipes.

AEC also estimated annual home heating costs for an average Massachusetts home using different heating options and found that by the mid-2030’s heating with air-source heat pumps, ground-source heat pumps, and/or networked geothermal systems will be more affordable than heating with fossil gas.

Link to White Paper

Return to Our Work

Equity Assessment of Electrification Incentives in the District of Columbia

Client: The Office of the People’s Counsel for the District of Columbia

Authors: Tanya Stasio, Bryndis Woods, PhD. Joshua R. Castigliego, Liz Stanton, PhD

December 2021

On behalf of the Office of the People’s Counsel for the District of Columbia, Researcher Tanya Stasio, Senior Researcher Bryndis Woods, PhD, Researcher Joshua Castigliego, and Senior Economist Liz Stanton, PhD examine a potential pathway for reducing emissions in the District of Columbia: equitable electrification–a transition away from fossil fuels while taking into consideration equity implications, in both existing and future decarbonization efforts.

A baseline equity analysis of the distribution of energy expenditures, median income and other vulnerability indicators reveals significant disparities across the District. To account for the existing disparities of income and access within the District and ensure beneficial electrification efforts are equitable, AEC identified the following priorities: (1)  Ensuring that community engagement influences DC Public Service Commission and District Government decision-making regarding beneficial electrification programs; (2) Prioritizing beneficial electrification investments in neighborhoods impacted by environmental injustice and addressing common decarbonization barriers, and; (3) Ensuring that beneficial electrification programs do not increase the energy burden for EJ and other vulnerable communities.

Link to Report

Media Coverage

Media Coverage

Return to Our Work

PJM's Capacity Market: Clearing Prices, Power Plants, and Environmental Justice

Authors: Joshua R. Castigliego, Liz Stanton, PhD, Sagal Alisalad, Tanya Stasio, Eliandro Tavares

October 2021 (Updated November 2021)

Researcher Joshua Castigliego, Senior Economist Liz Stanton, PhD, Assistant Researcher Sagal Alisalad, Researcher Tanya Stasio, and Assistant Researcher Eliandro Tavares prepared a report reviewing the economics of power plants in the PJM region, focusing on the "capacity payments" given to owners of generating units that promise to be available if needed to generate power at times of peak customer demand. AEC finds that PJM has consistently overestimated its peak demand and as a result spent too much money on capacity payments, and generating units—including many in or near Environmental Justice (EJ) communities—are kept online despite being uneconomic and unnecessary to provide reliable electric service.

AEC adjusted PJM’s forecasts and market design to better represent customer demand and other market conditions, and estimated the prices that individual generating units bid into the 2021/22 capacity auction, which took place in 2018. The actual bids by power plant owners are not made public, so we model them based on available cost and revenue data. PJM’s overestimate of customer demand and costs of new generating units raises market clearing prices and capacity payments to power plant owners, resulting in what we call a “fat market” with payments made to unnecessary power plants and higher costs to customers. In place of PJM’s $140 per megawatt-day (MW-day) fat market clearing price, we estimate a clearing price of $100 to $104 per MW-day to serve customer needs without adding unnecessary costs. Our leaner, adjusted clearing price would lower customer bills without sacrificing reliable electric service and put an end to capacity payments propping up the bottom lines of uneconomic power plants, many of them in or near EJ communities.

Link to Report (Updated 11/30/2021)

Link to Presentation for PJM Cities & Communities Coalition

Return to Our Work

Assessment of Backup Diesel Generators in Massachusetts and New York City

Client: Bloom Energy

Authors: Joshua R. Castigliego, Tanya Stasio, Sagal Alisalad, Liz Stanton, PhD

August 2021

On behalf of Bloom Energy, Researchers Joshua Castigliego and Tanya Stasio, Assistant Researcher Sagal Alisalad, and Senior Economist Liz Stanton, PhD prepared two reports assessing backup diesel generators in Massachusetts and New York City. AEC compiled inventories of backup diesel generators in each jurisdiction based on publicly available data and reviewed the quantity, combined capacity, proximity to environmental justice (EJ) communities, and emissions impact of backup diesel generators.

AEC found that there is an abundance of backup diesel generators throughout both areas that are commonly sited near EJ communities and represent a considerable—and largely avoidable—source of air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions that threaten public health and the environment.

Link to Massachusetts Report

Link to New York City Report

Link to Download Shapefile for Massachusetts Environmental Justice Communities

Link to Download Shapefile for New York City Environmental Justice Communities

Return to Our Work

Comments on 2021 Guidance Towards Updating the U.S. Social Cost of Greenhouse Gases

Client: Friends of the Earth

Authors: Liz Stanton, PhD, Chirag Lala, and Tanya Stasio

June 2021

Director and Senior Economist Liz Stanton, PhD and Research Assistants Chirag Lala and Tanya Stasio prepared comments on the 2021 guidance towards updating the U.S. social cost of greenhouse gases (SC-GHG) on behalf of Friends of the Earth.
AEC staff recommend that the current revision to the U.S. SC-GHG: (1) Estimate climate damages in a single model; (2) Include climate damages around the world; (3) Value for future climate impacts; (4) Place equal value on all people, all families, and all communities; (5) Set fair and effective emission reduction targets, and; (6) Have a clear process for updating the SC-GHGs over time.

Link to Comments

Link to News Release, Common Dreams

Link to News Release, Friends of the Earth

Link to News Release, Red, Green and Blue

Return to Our Work

Conditional Benefits of Sustainable Community Microgrids

Client: GreenRoots

Authors:
Joshua R. Castigliego, Tanya Stasio, and Eliandro Tavares

May 2021

On behalf of GreenRoots, Researcher Joshua Castigliego, Research Assistant Tanya Stasio, and Assistant Researcher Eliandro Tavares prepared a policy brief on the impacts of community microgrids on vulnerable populations. AEC staff defined “sustainable community microgrids” as independently controlled energy systems that, depending on their design, have the potential to enhance grid resilience, lower electric bills, improve public health, and strengthen local communities while prioritizing equitable outcomes.

Link to Policy Brief

Return to Our Work

What the COVID-19 Pandemic Can Teach Us About Climate Justice

Authors: Sagal Alisalad, Eliandro Tavares, Tanya Stasio, and Myisha Majumder

February 2021

The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic has had massive impacts on nearly all aspects of human life—from jobs to food security to healthcare. Black, Indigenous, and people of color (BIPOC) are disproportionately impacted by this unprecedented health crisis as a result of preexisting socioeconomic and environmental disadvantages. Assistant Researchers Sagal Alisalad and Eliandro Tavares, and Research Assistants Tanya Stasio and Myisha Majumder prepared an AEC policy brief that focuses on the relationship between preexisting racial inequality and the economic and health consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic. In this brief, AEC finds a substantial overlap between vulnerability to COVID-19 and vulnerability to climate change. Much like the global climate crisis, some groups, especially Environmental Justice communities, are more likely to bear the brunt of the ongoing health crisis.

Link to Policy Brief

Return to Our Work